I don’t usually just blurt out my feelings in emails to my email subscribers. After all, tens of thousands of subscribers (like you) trust me to give them quality guidance about homeschool science each month. And I’m grateful for this trust. People probably don’t want to hear about my daily frustrations (yes, I get frustrated too
But this made me so mad, I just have to share it. Besides, it may affect you too.
On occasion, I review other homeschool science curriculum to make sure I’m not missing any good ideas as I continue to add to my own e-Science curriculum and Science Mastery programs. This time, I was looking at one of the most popular curriculum available (I won’t mention the name out of professional courtesy). As I researched it, here’s what I found that made me so mad:
They didn’t even try the experiments before they put them in their own books!
Then they sold them to thousands of homeschoolers. It turns out they hired professional researchers and writers (not scientists) to gather “typical” science experiments and explanations for each topic from other science textbooks and online resources. They never even took the time to try the experiments.
Ask any college science student what would happen if they turned in a report with explanations and results of an experiment without actually doing the experiment themselves. If they’re lucky, they just get an F on the assignment. Depending on the assignment, stricter schools will suspend them or maybe even kick them out.
It turns out that this company got so many complaints that experiments didn’t work that they recently decided to have one of their employees go through the book and do the experiments so they could correct them.
And they’re still one of the top homeschool science curriculum. So I looked at other curriculum publishers, and started asking questions.
It got worse.
It seems that quite a few other science curriculum publishers do the same thing. Their books are not written by scientists and they have NEVER actually tried the experiments they tell kids to do. Some said that the authors of their curriculum were “confidential.” I don’t know about you, but I don’t want my kids being educated by material from someone who refuses to reveal their name, let alone their qualifications.
No wonder it’s so frustrating to kids and parents to get the experiments to work, let alone learn much from them.
If you’ve ever been frustrated trying to get an experiment from some textbook to work, perhaps you can relate (I know I can). It’s even worse if you don’t have a background in science yourself. Plus, if you were hoping your kids could really learn science on their own (without you there with them), it’s even more frustrating.
And, I know I feel guilty putting my kids through dry, boring material that I know isn’t as good as they deserve.
Okay, I’m done with my rant.
Whatever you do for science this year, PLEASE make sure that your kids are learning from a curriculum that was created by someone who is actually a scientist, AND who has actually done the experiments in it.
How can you tell these things?
Well, sometimes it’s obvious (Like in my Science Mastery and e-Science curriculum, you see me personally on the videos guiding your kids step-by-step through the experiments).
But, if you’re going for a curriculum that is mostly book-based (i.e. few videos or live online presentations), call or email the publisher (or company that sells it) and ask these questions:
“Who wrote this curriculum? What are the authors names?”
“What is their background in science?”
and “Has someone at your company tested out all of the experiments in the curriculum?”
If you get an answer like “That’s confidential” or “Our research team”, it’s probably time to look for another curriculum.
I mean, do you really feel comfortable immersing your child in material from a company that won’t even tell you who wrote it? I know I don’t. My kids deserve better.
BOTTOM LINE:
Get a science curriculum for your kids that was created by someone who knows science and has actually done the experiments themselves.
I’m sure you know that I sell complete top-of-the line curriculum that also include all the parts and pieces you’ll need for 1 to 3 years of science education. Me or one of my staff personally takes your kids through the experiments in the curriculum using step-by-step videos. You don’t need to be there yourself, and you don’t even need to buy any parts – they’re all included.
These top-of-the-line curriculum are called Science Mastery.
I’ll warn you, they are not for everybody – these are only for parents who are really serious about giving their kids the best homeschool science education available. If you don’t think science learning is important, please stop reading now (but please…do give your kids some consistent science education).
So, I recently had a special discount on Science Mastery programs just for my private e-Science members (These programs almost NEVER go on sale – this was a very limited special). But given these challenges I’ve discovered with other popular curriculum, I’ve decided to made this discount available to all my email subscribers. I figure this gives as many kids as possible the chance to get a great science education.
If you want to learn more about my Science Mastery programs, go to this link now:
www.SuperchargedScience.com/smpl8-1.htm
Regardless of whether Science Mastery is right for you, PLEASE ask questions before you invest in any science curriculum or program you’re considering. I know you want to do the best you possibly can for your kids.
Thanks for being so devoted to your children
Warmly,
Aurora